Skip to main content

Article

Best practices for the medical management of high-risk workers’ comp and auto no-fault claims

Robert Hall, MD, Medical Director, Optum Workers’ Comp and Auto No-Fault

September 22, 2025

In this article

Patients who have experienced catastrophic and high-risk injuries in the workplace or from an auto accident face complex medical, social, and psychological challenges. While these challenges are distinctive from patient to patient, how they are managed throughout the life of the claim will significantly affect the patient’s recovery. For claims professionals and medical management teams, success lies in understanding the whole patient — their history, current needs, living environment, and support systems — and coordinating care carefully and proactively to remove barriers to recovery.

Key factors for effective medical management

Individuals with severe injuries often feel overwhelmed. Pain, limited mobility, financial strain, and fear about the future can compound into hopelessness. Negative emotions such as anger or depression can worsen physical symptoms, especially pain. Additional stressors such as delays in claims handling, even when relatively minor, can intensify feelings of uncertainty and worry.

For these reasons, it’s vitally important to take an integrated approach when managing high-risk claims. While the primary focus is to treat the injuries, the patient’s comorbid conditions and emotional well-being will play into their recovery prospects. The transition from care facility to home is also important. The injured person must be transitioned home safely, have ready access to needed equipment and services, and caregivers should have the training needed to support recovery goals. The following sections outline some of the most important priorities in effectively managing the medical aspects of high-risk claims.

Hospital or care facility discharge planning

Discharge planning is a sensitive and critical stage. Poorly coordinated discharges from the hospital or care facility dramatically increase the risk of additional medical complications and hospital readmissions. Best practices include:

  • Discussing discharge needs early, and being sensitive to the emotions of the patient and their family
  • Avoiding Friday, weekend, or holiday discharges
  • Confirming safe transportation arrangements
  • Planning ongoing transportation for medical follow-up visits
  • Having translation services available when needed

Comorbid condition management

Pre-existing conditions such as diabetes, asthma, and heart disease often complicate recovery. For example, uncontrolled diabetes may slow wound healing; asthma may limit rehabilitation exercises. Pre-existing conditions should be actively managed along with the primary injury.

Medication safety

Medication safety is one of the most difficult aspects of managing high-risk cases. During hospitalization and rehabilitation, medication regimens often change significantly from those in place prior to the admission. Without careful medication reconciliation, patients may continue to take discontinued medications alongside new ones, leading to dangerous drug interactions, duplications in medication therapy, or overdoses.

Best practices include:

  • Confirming an accurate medication list at both admission and discharge from the hospital or care facility
  • Ensuring prescriptions can be filled and ready for the patient before their discharge
  • Training caregivers for any complex care needs, especially for injections or feeding tubes
  • Performing a medication reconciliation upon return to the home to validate medication accuracy
  • Securing controlled substances with lock boxes and frequent inventories

Durable medical equipment needs

Selecting, delivering, and training patients to use DME is another cornerstone of safe medical management. The right equipment — wheelchairs, lifts, or prosthetic devices — can maximize a patient’s level of independence.  For example, appropriate wheelchair selection requires assessing the patient’s long-term needs, their upper body strength, and their ability to provide pressure relief to help prevent skin breakdown.

Key considerations:

  • Obtaining occupational or physical therapist input, ideally through a home safety evaluation
  • Ensuring medical devices are properly fitted and equipment is appropriate for the patient and the home
  • Choosing between temporary rentals and permanent purchases of DME
  • Scheduling DME delivery and providing training on its use before discharge

Home health care needs

The shortage of home health providers makes early planning critical. Also keep in mind that home care teams are now managing increasingly complex conditions that require advanced training and careful coordination.

To be proactive, the claims professional should:

  • Arrange home health services well in advance of hospital or care facility discharge
  • Confirm staff qualifications and scope of practice through a qualified agency
  • Develop contingency plans for staffing challenges to reduce the risk of potential hospital readmissions or medical complications

Amputation and prosthetic needs

Amputation cases demand attention beyond prosthetic fitting. Unhealed wounds, phantom limb pain, and PTSD are common. Functionality depends on pre-injury activity, comorbidities, cognition, and weight. Because prosthetic devices involve large financial investments, second opinions from independent prosthetists can confirm treatment plans and prevent coding irregularities.

Home and vehicle modifications

To support the patient once they return home, modifications are often needed — ramps, accessible bathrooms, or vehicle adaptations. Claims professionals should distinguish between essential modifications and non-essential upgrades. And because modification projects can take months, occupational therapy evaluations and contractor estimates should begin early.

Working together to provide comprehensive support

Behind every catastrophic claim is a person facing one of the hardest times in their life. While clinical and technical support is vital in helping the patient recover, compassion transforms the process. I have personally seen the difference for patients when their needs are considered proactively and addressed efficiently. When this happens, the patient and their family are free to focus solely on the patient recovering.

I cannot emphasize enough the profound impact of compassionate claims management. By anticipating barriers and ensuring that patients receive what they need when they need it, claims professionals foster hope, resilience, and better outcomes.

Medical management for high-risk claims demands coordination across the healthcare spectrum, including medications, comorbidities, DME, home health, prosthetic devices, discharge planning, and home modifications. And ultimately, it’s the compassionate and proactive engagement from claims professionals that plays a vital role in establishing the course of recovery for the injured persons we serve.

Related content

For a detailed road map for managing high-risk claims, I encourage you to read Top 10 factors in the successful management of high-risk claims. This white paper, which draws from my years of experience working with catastrophic injury cases, outlines what I have seen to be the most critical factors in effective medical management throughout the claim lifecycle. It also provides questions for the claims professional to pose to the care team and explains why these questions can help to ensure that all key areas have been effectively managed to support the best possible recovery.

Contact us

If you would like to learn more about our clinically based personal approach to providing cost-efficient, whole-person care, we’d love to connect. Contact us at expectmore@optum.com.

Article disclaimer-WorkCompWire

Also published through our media partnership with WorkCompWire, an online news service offering valuable information regarding workers’ compensation and related issues.